Grade Our Essays vs MagicSchool
Looking for a MagicSchool alternative?
MagicSchool is a broad AI platform with dozens of teacher and student tools. Grade Our Essays does one job: grading student writing on your state rubric, with you approving every score.
No credit card required.
Side by side
Grade Our Essays and MagicSchool compared
MagicSchool details come from its public website, checked November 11, 2026. Plans change, so check their site for the latest.
| Feature | Grade Our Essays | MagicSchool |
|---|---|---|
| Built for | K-12 ELA writing, grades 3 to 12 | An AI platform with 80+ teacher tools and 50+ student tools across all subjects. Essay feedback is one tool |
| Rubrics | 500+ official state writing rubrics covering all 50 states, including STAAR | The teacher's own rubric in its Class Writing Feedback tool |
| Score for each rubric trait | Yes, every trait on every essay | Yes, a score breakdown by rubric criteria |
| Evidence behind scores | Quotes the student's own sentences for each score | Shows evidence supporting the scoring |
| Teacher approval before students see it | Always. Nothing is released until you approve it | Yes in Class Writing Feedback. In Student Rooms, students use AI tools directly |
| How students get in | Class code. Students do not create accounts | Join link, code or Google Classroom. SSO with Google, Microsoft, Clever or ClassLink |
| Integrations | One-click share of assignments to Google Classroom (no grade sync) | Google Classroom, Canvas, Schoology, Microsoft, Clever and ClassLink (some on Enterprise only) |
| Free option | 14-day free trial, no credit card | Free plan with standard usage limits |
| Paid plans | From $4.99/month, limited by assignments per month. Schools and districts by quote | Plus: $12.99/month, or $99.96/year. Enterprise by quote |
| Student privacy | FERPA and COPPA compliant. Student writing is never used to train AI models | FERPA, COPPA and SOC 2 listed. Does not use children's personal information to train AI for general, commercial or non-educational purposes |
An honest take
Which one fits you
Choose MagicSchool if
- You want one platform for lesson plans, quizzes and student AI tools, not just grading
- Your district wants SSO through Clever or ClassLink and district-wide admin controls
- Your students already write in Google Docs or OneDrive and you want feedback added there
Choose Grade Our Essays if
- Grading writing is the job you need done, every week
- You want official state test rubrics built in, not rubrics you have to recreate
- You want each score to quote the student's own sentences
- You want students writing in one place with text-to-speech, speech-to-text and graphic organizers
FAQ
Grade Our Essays vs MagicSchool: questions
Is Grade Our Essays a good alternative to MagicSchool for grading?
If grading essays is your main need, yes: it is built only for that, with official state rubrics included. If you want lesson planning, quizzes and student chat tools in one subscription, MagicSchool covers far more ground.
Can I use both?
Yes. Many teachers plan with a general AI tool and grade with a dedicated one. Grade Our Essays does not need any other tool to work.
Does Grade Our Essays work with Google Classroom?
You can post an assignment to Google Classroom in one click, with the title and link filled in. Students then join with the class code. Grades are not synced back to Classroom.
How does pricing work?
Teachers start with a 14-day free trial, no credit card. Paid plans are billed monthly or yearly and are limited by assignments per month. Schools and districts can request a free pilot.
Sources
- MagicSchool pricing
- MagicSchool: Class Writing Feedback
- MagicSchool FAQ
- MagicSchool student data policy
MagicSchool is a trademark of its owner. Grade Our Essays is not affiliated with MagicSchool.
See it on your own essays
Start a free trial, grade one class set on your state rubric, and compare the results with your current tool.
Start your free 14-day trial