STAAR writing for Texas teachers
The STAAR ECR rubric, explained.
How Texas scores extended and short constructed responses, what each point means, and how to give students practice scores on the same rubric before test day.
No credit card required.
ECR scoring
Five points, two traits
Every STAAR extended constructed response is scored on a 5-point rubric with two traits. Two scorers rate each essay and their scores are added, so students can earn up to 10 points. Students write an informational or argumentative essay (opinion in the lower grades) using evidence from the texts they read.
| Trait | Points | What scorers look for |
|---|---|---|
| Development and Organization of Ideas | 0 to 3 | A clear central idea or claim, a structure that moves the reader through it, and evidence from the texts that is relevant and explained. |
| Conventions | 0 to 2 | Sentence construction, grammar, capitalization, punctuation and spelling that are mostly correct for the grade level. |
The zero rule
A 0 in development means a 0 in conventions
If an essay earns 0 points for Development and Organization of Ideas, it also earns 0 for Conventions, no matter how clean the writing is. That is why a response that ignores the prompt or uses no text evidence can earn no points at all.
Grade Our Essays applies this rule automatically on STAAR rubrics, so a practice score never looks better than the real test would allow.
SCR scoring
Short constructed responses: 1 or 2 points
Reading SCRs ask for a short, text-based answer and are scored on a 2-point rubric written for each prompt: full credit needs a clear, correct answer supported by accurate evidence from the text. Writing SCRs, such as revising or editing a sentence, are scored on a 1-point rubric.
Scored by machine first
Why rubric practice matters more now
Since December 2023, TEA has scored most STAAR constructed responses with an automated scoring engine, with a share routed to human scorers. The engine scores against the same rubric, so students who practice answering the prompt, using evidence and explaining it are practicing exactly what gets scored.
Official rubrics, released tests and scoring guides are on the TEA STAAR resources page.
Practice on the real rubric
Grade STAAR practice essays in minutes
- Every essay scored on both ECR traits, with the zero rule applied
- Each score quotes the student's own sentences as evidence
- Revision steps students can act on before the next practice round
- You review and adjust every score before students see it
- See which trait the whole class needs to work on next
Included in Grade Our Essays
Texas rubrics in the library
Pick any of these when you create an assignment.
- TELPAS Writing Rubric - Grades 2 and 3 - Informational EssayECR · Grade 3
- TELPAS Writing Rubric - Grades 2 and 3 - Narrative EssayECR · Grade 3
- TELPAS Writing Rubric - Grades 2 and 3 - Procedural EssayECR · Grade 3
- Grades 3-5 - ECR - Reading Language Arts - InformationalECR · Grades 3 to 5
- Grades 3–5 - ECR - Reading Language Arts - Argumentative/OpinionECR · Grades 3 to 5
- Grades 3–5 - ECR - Spanish Reading Language Arts - Argumentative and OpinionECR · Grades 3 to 5
- Grades 3–5 - ECR - Spanish Reading Language Arts - InformationalECR · Grades 3 to 5
- TELPAS Writing Rubric - Grades 4-12 ExpositoryECR · Grades 4 to 12
- TELPAS Writing Rubric - Grades 4-12 NarrativeECR · Grades 4 to 12
- TELPAS Writing Rubric - Grades 4-12 ReflectiveECR · Grades 4 to 12
- Grades 6-ECII - ECR - Reading Language Arts - Argumentative/OpinionECR · Grades 6 to 12
- Grades 6-ECII - ECR - Reading Language Arts - InformationalECR · Grades 6 to 12
- ACT Writing RubricECR · Grades 9 to 12
- SAT - Argument EssayECR · Grades 9 to 12
- SAT - Rhetorical AnalysisECR · Grades 9 to 12
- SAT - Synthesis EssayECR · Grades 9 to 12
- Grades 3-5 - SCR - Reading Language Arts - Grammar/RevisionSCR · Grades 3 to 5
- Grades 3-5 - SCR - Reading Language Arts - Reading/AnalysisSCR · Grades 3 to 5
- Grades 3-5 - SCR - Science/Social Studies - AnalysisSCR · Grades 3 to 5
- Grades 3-5 - SCR - Spanish Reading Language Arts - Grammar/RevisionSCR · Grades 3 to 5
- Grades 3-5 - SCR - Spanish Reading Language Arts - Reading/AnalysisSCR · Grades 3 to 5
- Grades 3-5 - SCR - Spanish Science/Social Studies - Reading/AnalysisSCR · Grades 3 to 5
- Grades 6 - High School - SCR - Science/Social Studies - AnalysisSCR · Grades 6 to 12
- Grades 6-EC II - SCR - Reading Language Arts - Grammar/RevisionSCR · Grades 6 to 12
- Grades 6-EC II - SCR - Reading Language Arts - Reading/AnalysisSCR · Grades 6 to 12
FAQ
STAAR ECR questions
How many points is the STAAR ECR worth?
The ECR rubric has 5 points: up to 3 for Development and Organization of Ideas and up to 2 for Conventions. Each essay is scored twice and the two scores are added, so an ECR is worth up to 10 points on the test.
What happens if an ECR scores 0 for development and organization?
It also receives 0 for Conventions. Grade Our Essays applies this rule automatically when it scores on a STAAR rubric, so practice scores match how the test is scored.
How is the STAAR SCR scored?
Reading SCRs are scored on a 2-point rubric written for each prompt. Writing SCRs use a 1-point rubric.
Which grades take the STAAR ECR?
STAAR Reading Language Arts includes constructed responses in grades 3 to 8 and on the English I and English II end-of-course exams. Spanish versions are available for grades 3 to 5.
Is a Grade Our Essays score the same as a STAAR score?
No. It is practice scoring on the same rubric structure, meant to show students where they stand before test day. You review every score before students see it.
Give every student a STAAR practice score this week
Assign a prompt on the STAAR rubric, let students write, and review scored first drafts with the evidence behind each point.
Start your free 14-day trial